Welcome to Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza
At Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza, a gem located in Morristown, NJ, we celebrate the art of authentic Italian cuisine. Drawing inspiration from time-honored recipes, we pride ourselves on our handcrafted meatballs, made from premium beef sirloin and blended with imported cheeses for a taste that's truly exceptional. Our wood-fired pizzas, like the signature White Pie and Sausage & Broccoli Rabe, feature homemade mozzarella and carefully selected ingredients, delivering bold flavors with every bite. With a BYOB option and a warm ambiance, Millie’s is the perfect destination for both casual meals and special occasions. Join us and experience Italian tradition at its finest!
Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Millie’s lived up to the hype. The food was actually exceptional and I can be a tough critic with pasta and pizza. The meatballs in vodkas sauce are actually divine! Ordered family style for 8 and everyone loved all of the plates. Also awesome they offer to go options from their menu favorites!
This pizza was really good (if not a little pricey)! The bottom crust was a little too soft for my taste but all the flavors were there - I went with the signature coal fired pie. My friend went with a meatball sub and it was HUGE. Overall we really liked the food, ambience was decent and staff were nice enough. I enjoyed our stop here - I need to try the the wood fired personal pies next time I come back.
Exceptional Experience for a Large Birthday Dinner We recently hosted a birthday dinner for 16 guests at Millie's and were thoroughly impressed. From the moment we arrived, the service was impeccable. Our table was set with water glasses and wine glasses, perfectly accommodating our BYOB request. We opted for family-style dining, and the kitchen expertly paced the dishes, ensuring a delightful flow throughout the meal. The ambiance was refined and relaxed, offering a bit of a more upscale dining experience than a typical pizzeria. Every dish was delicious! Millie's has quickly become our go-to spot for both special occasions and casual takeout pizza nights. We highly recommend them for any group gathering and look forward to hosting future events there.
Their pizza it’s great, I highly recommended it. But before you order a pizza make sure you try their grilled oysters, and keep the plate with the sauce . Don’t let the server take it, so you can deep the pizzas crust into that delicious sauce.
We absolutely love Millie’s! I don't usually eat meatballs, but theirs are amazing. You can't go wrong with the vodka pizza—we definitely prefer the wood-fired option over coal. The mozzarella is also to die for. Plus, it's BYOB, which makes it even more fun! Highly recommend!
I had the meatballs and mozzarella which was fabulous. My colleague had a pizza which he was blown away with the flavours and uniqueness. Can't score down in the atmosphere as we popped in on our way to the airport at a quiet time. Inside Milles was lovely, homely, and yet spacious. Definitely would go again next time I'm in the neighbourhood.
Great Italian food and big portion’s. Parking is difficult due to street parking only. Little of a wait to get your food depending on the time you go. I went on a Saturday around 1pm and they were busy so of course the wait was a little long but worth it.
Our server Shane was awesome! He was amazing while juggling multiple tables on a Saturday he remained attentive. The manager was extremely kind and accommodating. Food was excellent. We got the fig and goat cheese pizza but ate it too quick to get a picture. Can’t wait to come back
Location
-
60 South St, Morristown, NJ 07960, United States Hotline: +1 973-267-4992
Welcome to the Heart of Italian Comfort Food: Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza
Nestled in the charming town of Morristown, NJ, at 60 South St, Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza stands as a delightful tribute to authentic Italian cuisine. This restaurant is not just a pizzeria; it is a culinary experience that showcases the rich flavors and comforting styles of traditional Italian cooking.
Signature Offerings
- Coal-Fired Pizza: The pizza at Millie’s is nothing short of exceptional. Whether you opt for the Sm Meatball Parmesan Pizza, featuring homemade mozzarella, sautéed tomatoes, and delectable meatballs, or the Sm Sweet Sausage Pizza, loaded with sweet Italian sausage and fresh basil, you are in for a treat. The carefully crafted flavors come together beautifully, creating a memorable dish that artfully balances heartiness and freshness.
- Pot of Balls: For pasta lovers, the Pot of Balls is a standout feature. This generous serving of 12 marinara balls comes paired with 2 lbs of dried Millie's pasta, offering a comforting family-style dish that evokes the warmth of Italian home cooking.
- Platters: The restaurant's platters like the Eggplant Parmesan Platter and the Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Platter offer a refined dining experience. Each dish is executed with precision, providing a delightful blend of textures and flavors.
Atmosphere and Service
Millie’s is not only celebrated for its food but also for its welcoming ambiance. The setting strikes a balance between upscale dining and casual comfort, perfect for both special occasions and relaxed evenings out. The staff are noted for their attentive service and willingness to accommodate large groups, making it an ideal venue for gatherings of friends and family.
Customer Favorites
- Many guests rave about the vodka pizza and often suggest the wood-fired option for its smoky undertones, while others can't resist the scrumptious grilled oysters, which some have recommended pairing with the pizza crust to deepen that flavorful experience.
- Many reviews reflect a common sentiment: there is something special about the meatballs at Millie’s. Even those who typically shy away from meatballs find themselves enamored with the dish, declaring them divine.
Conclusion
Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza has successfully positioned itself as a go-to spot in Morristown for both food lovers and pizza enthusiasts alike. With its dedication to quality ingredients and authentic flavors, it is a place where every bite tells a story of culinary heritage. So next time you're in the mood for delicious Italian comfort food, whether gathered with friends or enjoying a cozy night in, Millie’s is ready to satisfy your cravings and elevate your dining experience.
For inquiries or reservations, contact them at +1 973-267-4992.